Every season tells countless different stories — about grit, growth, heartbreak, and glory. But once the final whistle blows, we’re left with those who stood just a little taller when it mattered most.

This year’s Times News Wrestling All-Star First Team celebrates 11 athletes — six boys, five girls — selected from across our coverage area. They come from different rooms, different programs, and different paths. Some battled through injuries. Some shocked the region. Some made history. All of them left their mark.

Each earned this recognition through tireless hours on the mat, long bus rides, early weigh-ins, and battles most people never saw. Their records speak volumes, but the character they showed speaks louder.

At the top stand our 2024-25 Wrestlers of the Year:

Luke Fugazzotto, a powerhouse from Northwestern who anchored his team all season long.

And Brenda Banks, of Panther Valley, a three-time state champion who continues to redefine what’s possible.

They aren’t just All-Stars. They’re the story of this season.

Each selection is listed below in alphabetical order, featured with a bio highlighting their accomplishments, milestones, and what made their season special.

Mahanoy’s Rory Dixon, who attends Marian but wrestles for the Golden Bears through a co-op between the schools, is recognized for his performance this season on the First Team.

BOYS

First Team

Luke Fugazzotto, Northwestern, Jr.

(Boys Wrestler of the Year)

A leader on and off the mat, Fugazzotto capped off his junior season with authority. The Northwestern standout racked up 50 wins, claimed his second district title, placed a career best second at regionals, and made a deep run at states, where he earned his second career medal with a seventh-place result, finishing as one of the top wrestlers in Pennsylvania at 172 pounds in his third appearance in Hershey. Known for his relentless pace and punishing top game, Fugazzotto consistently set the tone for his team throughout the season, going 50-5 and earning his 100th career victory and helping the Tigers qualify for the PIAA Team Championships, where the squad won its opening match. Whether it was a critical pin in a dual match or a clutch win in a tournament final, he rose to the moment time and again. A multi-time state qualifier and the heart of Northwestern’s lineup, Fugazzotto, who has a career record of 127-21 and owns 96 career pins, has cemented a legacy of excellence and leadership that the Tigers will be looking to build on next year.

QUOTE: “I have coached both Luke and Nolan (Koehler) since they were young. Both of their personalities are reserved but they are competitors in everything they do. Luke had a great season with 38 pins, he will be looking to place high on the state podium next year. For both of them, I would expect a significant improvement from this year. I am confident they will both put in the work to do so.” – Northwestern head coach Joe Killar.

Evan Gillespie, Pleasant Valley, Jr.

Gillespie has emerged as a standout wrestler for Pleasant Valley, particularly at 215 pounds. This past season, he achieved a 30-7 overall record, demonstrating consistent dominance on the mat and a big jump from his 13-14 mark as a sophomore. At the District 11 tournament, Gillespie secured a third-place finish, further solidifying his reputation in Class 3A. His stellar performances throughout the season earned him a spot on the EPC Wrestling All-Stars 2nd Team, highlighting his exceptional skills and contributions to his team. Gillespie’s prowess extends beyond regional accolades; he also competed at the Northeast Regional 3A tournament for the first time, showcasing his talent on a broader stage. His continuous growth and achievements reflect his dedication to the sport and position him as one to watch next season.

Nolan Koehler, Northwestern, Fr.

In his first varsity season, freshman Koehler of Northwestern Lehigh displayed remarkable skill and resilience in the 152-pound weight class. He concluded the season with a 30-19 record, including four wins by decision, three by major decision, six by technical fall, and 15 by fall. His postseason performance was noteworthy, securing a second-place finish at the District 11 2A Championships and advancing to the Regionals, where he placed fifth to punch his ticket to states. Koehler secured his spot in Hershey with a thrilling 6-5 victory in the fifth-place match against Seth Karpulk (Tulpehocken). His impressive debut sets a promising foundation for his wrestling career at Northwestern Lehigh.

QUOTE: “I have coached both Luke (Fugazzotto) and Nolan since they were young. Both of their personalities are reserved but they are competitors in everything they do. Nolan will be looking also looking to get on the podium. It was a valuable experience for Nolan to wrestle at Hershey and will prepare him to place out there this year. For both of them, I would expect a significant improvement from this year. I am confident they will both put in the work to do so.” - Northwestern head coach Joe Killar.

Dillon Lombardi, Palmerton, Sr.

Lombardi concluded his high school wrestling career with a series of remarkable achievements that underscore his dedication and skill. In his senior season, Lombardi amassed a 42-11 record, marking a significant improvement from his earlier years. A pivotal milestone was securing his 100th career victory at the Southeast Regional tournament, a moment that fulfilled a long-held personal goal. He advanced to the PIAA Championships, where he showcased resilience by winning his first consolation match after an initial loss, ultimately concluding his state run with a 1-2 record. Lombardi’s journey from 13 wins as a freshman to 104 career victories exemplifies his growth and commitment, leaving a lasting legacy at Palmerton High School.

QUOTE: “Dillon is an outstanding human being. We are lucky to have so many great kids in our program and he’s definitely another example of that. What jumps out right away to me is his work ethic. He outworks everyone. He was really driven throughout his career but after he came up just short of getting to Hershey last year, he became obsessed with perfecting his craft. He really worked hard all off-season to get stronger, and make sure nobody would be in better shape than him. In doing so he became a leader that everyone wanted to emulate. We have guys putting in similar work mostly because of him. He deserves any positives that come his way. I am very proud of the man he has become and am excited to see how successful he is in everything he does in the future.” – Palmerton head coach Justin Petersen.

Andrew Mihalichko, Pleasant Valley, Sr.

Mihalichko has been a cornerstone of Pleasant Valley’s wrestling team, particularly at 285 pounds. Over his high school career, Mihalichko amassed a 53-49 record, reflecting his determination and growth within the sport. He achieved a 26-11 record, with 19 wins by fall this past season, and earned a fourth-place finish at the District 11 3A tournament to advance to regionals. His performance earned him a spot on the EPC Wrestling All-Stars 2nd Team, underscoring his impact in the league. At regionals, Mihalichko secured a 2-1 victory over Will Riley of Academy at Palumbo in the consolation rounds. However, his tournament concluded with a 6-0 loss to Crestwood’s Kyle Draina, ending his season with a 26-11 record. Mihalichko’s journey from a 6-18 record as a sophomore to his senior-year accolades exemplifies resilience and continuous improvement, leaving a lasting legacy on the program.

Special recognition:

Rory Dixon, Mahanoy (Marian), So.

Dixon has emerged as a key cog for Mahanoy Area’s wrestling team at 160 pounds. In the 2024-2025 season, he achieved a 32-11 record, underscoring his dedication and skill development. Dixon secured his spot at the prestigious PIAA Wrestling Championships held at the Giant Center in Hershey for the first time. In his opening match, he dominated with a 17-1 technical fall over Burrell’s Ben Catullo. Although he faced a setback in the subsequent round, Dixon’s performance at states marked a significant milestone in his wrestling journey, which included a fourth-place finish in his first appearance at the Southeast Regional tournament. Competing in the District 11 2A tournament, Dixon secured a third-place finish. Beyond individual accolades, Dixon’s efforts contributed to Mahanoy Area’s growing reputation in wrestling. His qualification for the PIAA Championships, alongside teammate Kyler Quick, highlighted the team’s rising stature. Dixon’s resilience, especially considering his history of knee injuries and surgeries, exemplifies his commitment to excellence. His achievements this season not only reflect his personal growth but also inspire his teammates and the broader Mahanoy Area wrestling community.

GIRLS

First Team

Brenda Banks, Panther Valley, Jr.

(Girls Wrestler of the Year)

There’s dominance — and then there’s Brenda Banks. The Panther Valley junior became a three-time state champion this season, cementing her place in wrestling history and finished the year with a 36-1 record. In four matches at states, the junior never had a bout get out of the first period and spent a total of 3:30 on the mat. In her last two matches, Banks pinned her opponents in a combined 0:52. Banks stepped on the mat ready to roll in the finals, pinning Southmoreland’s Zoey Murphy in 0:42 to claim her second PIAA title and third state championship overall, a result that drew a roar from the Giant Center crowd where Banks was a fan favorite. In the semis, Banks pinned Esther Reed of Big Spring in just 0:10. Reed placed third. Known for her intensity, technical precision, and unmatched work ethic, Banks didn’t just win — she overwhelmed her opponents. More than her accolades, though, she’s become a role model for younger girls in the sport, blazing a trail and showing what’s possible. As Banks prepares for her senior season, her legacy at Panther Valley and across the region is already secure.

QUOTE: “For Brenda, everything comes so naturally that I show her the move and within the first few attempts she’s already semi-proficient. The best part of it is, having both Alisa (Williams) and Brenda in the room and working together ensures that they are both being pushed to new heights. Brenda did exactly what was expected of her this season. Next season I expect Brenda to win her fourth state championship.” – Panther Valley head coach Kris Nalesnik.

Lily Decker, Pleasant Valley, Sr.

Decker has been a trailblazer for Pleasant Valley’s wrestling program at 235 pounds. Her journey reflects both personal growth and a commitment to advancing girls wrestling within her school and beyond. Decker concluded the season with an 8-10 overall record, demonstrating resilience and determination. She secured a fourth-place finish at the District 11 tournament and placed sixth at the regional tournament. Recognizing the need for dedicated opportunities, Decker actively advocated for the establishment of a girls’ wrestling team at Pleasant Valley. Her efforts culminated in the school board’s approval in January 2024, marking a significant milestone for female athletes in the district. In 2022, Decker represented Team Pennsylvania at the USA Junior National Duals in Tulsa, Oklahoma, competing with the U16 girls’ team and contributing to the state’s undefeated record. Her contributions extend beyond her individual achievements; she has been instrumental in shaping the wrestling landscape at Pleasant Valley, paving the way for future generations of female wrestlers.

Cassidy Litts, Lehighton, So.

In just her second year, Lehighton’s Cassidy Litts has emerged as a formidable competitor at 155 pounds. Compiling an impressive 20-6 record this season, she showcased her dominance with 15 pins. Notably, Litts secured a third-place finish with a pin in 0:28 at the District 11 Tournament, earning her a spot at regionals. At the Upper Dauphin Lady Trojan Tournament, she secured a second-place finish, while her teammate Claudia Pagotto placed third. In dual meet action, Litts delivered an impressive performance against Palmerton, pinning her opponent in just eight seconds at 170 pounds. Balancing her wrestling pursuits with contributions to Lehighton’s soccer team, Litts exemplifies dedication and versatility. As she continues to develop her skills, the future looks exceptionally bright for Litts – and the Indians.

QUOTE: “Cassidy is a naturally gifted athlete, but it is her work ethic, drive, willingness to learn, and her competitive nature that have made her an outstanding wrestler. As a sophomore with limited experience (she broke her neck last year and missed out on a chunk of the season) having a 20-win season against stiff competition is impressive. She is also an amazing leader as one of our captains this season, and she is doing this a sophomore! It is a pure pleasure to coach her and watch her work to improve her skills. This past season she made it to regionals and placed third in districts, so regarding next year a reasonable expectation is that she works to advance to states. Because girls wrestling does not divide up into AA and AAA for the post season, it makes if that much more difficult as a small school to compete against large schools such as Easton, Northampton, Parkland, etc. ... however, Cass is tenacious. I look forward to coaching her next season.” – Lehighton girls head coach Jennifer Lobasso.

Juliette Trout, Pleasant Valley, So.

Trout has rapidly ascended to prominence in Pleasant Valley’s girls wrestling program. In the 2024-2025 season, she achieved a 26-5 record, with 23 pins, two major decisions, and one technical fall. Trout secured third place at the District 11 Girls Wrestling Tournament and clinched the regional title in the 112-pound weight class, earning a state tournament berth for the second year in a row. At the East Penn Conference Girls Wrestling Championships, Trout went undefeated, pinning all three opponents in the first period to claim the 112-pound title. Her rapid rise and consistent dominance have established her as a leading figure in regional wrestling, with a promising future ahead.

Alisa Williams, Panther Valley, Jr.

Williams has been a pivotal member of Panther Valley’s girls wrestling team, competing in both the 170-pound and 190-pound weight classes. In the 2024-2025 season, she achieved a 33-10 record, reflecting her versatility and skill across multiple weight divisions. Williams secured a third-place finish at the District 11 tournament to qualify for regionals. She earned a fourth-place finish at the Southeast Regional, advancing to the state championships. At the PIAA Championships, Williams competed valiantly, winning her first match but narrowly missing placement honors. Her performance at states highlighted her growth and potential on the state level, and showed the progress she made after going 14-13 a year ago. She posted 25 of her 33 wins by pinfall this season. Williams’ dedication to her sport and her team has significantly contributed to the advancement of girls’ wrestling at Panther Valley, setting a strong foundation for future athletes.

QUOTE: “With Alisa, it doesn’t come quite as easily as it might for Brenda (Banks), but it is arguably more rewarding. She will need to practice a move 1,000 times to get it, but the best part is, she is willing to do exactly that. There is no legal method she is not willing to do to improve upon her skills. The best part of it is, having both Alisa and Brenda in the room and working together ensures that they are both being pushed to new heights. Alisa outperformed expectations, but has given herself a new floor for next year. I expect Alisa to collect a state medal next year as well.” – Panther Valley head coach Kris Nalesnik.

BOYS

Second Team

Aiden Sterling, Jim Thorpe; Lukas Croizier, Lehighton; Weston Killar, Northwestern; Cody Mazzocca, Northern Lehigh; Stephen Korte, Jim Thorpe; Vinnie Fugazzotto, Northwestern; Derek King, Palmerton.

Honorable Mention

Jacob Ferguson, Lehighton; Aiden Schlier, Tamaqua; Dillon Anthony, Palmerton; Marc Macias, Lehighton; Nikolas Schwartz, Jim Thorpe; Chase Sukanick, Northwestern; Vincent Taglieri, Palmerton; Konner Nalesnik, Lehighton; Jacob Hehn, Tamaqua; Jackson Bailey, Northwestern; Connor Messinger, Palmerton; Colby Townley, Northwestern; Jack Lucykanish, Lehighton.

GIRLS

Second Team

Anna Trelease, Northern Lehigh; Kyla McQuillen, Panther Valley; Mia Hall, Lehighton; Lillian Klotz, Lehighton; Cassidy Merkel, Palmerton; Kennedy Quinn, Lehighton; Lea Schaible, Palmerton; Anelia Bennick, Panther Valley; Isabella Altemose, Pleasant Valley.

Honorable Mention

Molly Ries, Palmerton; Kiely Kunkel, Tamaqua; Taylor Hawkins, Pleasant Valley; Skylar Benninger, Palmerton; Autumn Khuu, Northern Lehigh; Blayr Strawser, Lehighton; Addison Streubel, Lehighton; Zania Braewell, Northern Lehigh; Kailey Evans, Lehighton; Hailey Marsh, Pleasant Valley; Alivia Reed, Lehighton; Shayla Clay, Tamaqua; Abigayle Tower, Lehighton; Claudia Pagotto, Lehighton.